Can the Same Product Have Different GST Rates in Tally Prime? | How to Edit Product Details Easily

Call CA Tally HelpDesk +91 9205471661, 8368262875

Introduction

While working in accounting and GST compliance, two very common questions arise among business owners, accountants, and CA firms:

1. Can the same product have different GST rates?
2. Can product details be edited later in Tally Prime?

These questions are extremely important because incorrect GST rates or wrong product details can lead to GST mismatches, wrong billing, notices from the department, and inaccurate reports.

This article explains both questions in a simple, practical, and beginner-friendly way, specifically focusing on Tally Prime (including Tally Prime 7.0).

Can the Same Product Have Different GST Rates?

Short Answer

�� No, a single product (Stock Item) should not have multiple GST rates at the same time.

In Tally Prime, each product (Stock Item) can have only one GST rate.

Why Can’t One Product Have Multiple GST Rates?

GST law requires:

• One HSN code
• One applicable GST rate
  for a specific product under normal circumstances.

If the same product is assigned different GST rates:

• GST returns may show errors
• GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B mismatches can occur
• Incorrect tax liability may be calculated
• Compliance risk increases

Real-Life Scenarios Where Confusion Happens

Scenario 1: GST Rate Change Over Time

Example:

• Product taxed at 18% earlier
• GST reduced to 12% later

✔ Correct approach:

• Edit the existing product’s GST rate
• OR create a new product with revised GST rate, if required for reporting clarity

Scenario 2: Same Product Sold at Different Rates Due to Nature

Example:

• Printed books (0%)
• E-books (5%)

✔ Correct approach:

• Create separate stock items
  • “Book – Printed (GST 0%)”
  • “Book – Digital (GST 5%)”

Scenario 3: GST Rate Depends on Customer Type

Example:

• B2B vs B2C

❌ GST rate does not change based on customer
✔ GST rate depends on product classification, not buyer type

Best Practice: How to Handle Different GST Rates

Instead of using one product:

• Create multiple stock items
• Use clear naming

Example

• Cement OPC 43 Grade – GST 28%
• Cement OPC 53 Grade – GST 28%
• Service AMC – GST 18%
• Service Training – GST 18%

This keeps:

• GST returns clean
• Reports accurate
• Compliance risk low

Can I Edit Product Details Later in Tally Prime?

Short Answer

�� Yes, product details can be edited anytime in Tally Prime.

Tally Prime allows you to alter stock items easily, even after transactions are entered.

What Product Details Can Be Edited?

You can edit:

• Product name
• Stock group
• Unit of measurement
• GST applicability
• HSN / SAC code
• GST rate
• Opening stock (with caution)
• Godown / batch settings

How to Edit Product Details in Tally Prime (Step-by-Step)

Step 1: Open Alter Stock Item

1. Go to Gateway of Tally
2. Select Alter > Stock Item
3. Choose the product you want to edit

Step 2: Modify Required Fields

• Change GST rate
• Update HSN code
• Correct unit
• Edit product name

Step 3: Save Changes

• Press Ctrl + A to save

Changes apply immediately.

Important Precautions While Editing Product Details

⚠ Be careful when editing GST rates after transactions exist

• Old invoices may reflect revised rates in reports
• GST returns may change if recomputed

Best Practice

• If GST rate change is major and date-specific:
  • Create a new stock item
  • Stop using the old one for new invoices

Should You Edit or Create a New Product?

How This Impacts GST Returns & Reports

Correct product setup ensures:

• Accurate GST calculation
• Error-free GSTR-1 & GSTR-3B
• Clean reconciliation with GSTR-2B
• Proper item-wise sales reports
• Smooth audits

Why Take Expert Help from Binarysoft Technologies?

Powered by Binarysoft Technologies – Authorized Tally Partner

Binarysoft Technologies helps businesses avoid costly mistakes by providing:

• GST-ready product configuration
• Correct HSN & tax setup
• Product restructuring guidance
• Tally Prime training
• License sales, upgrades & support

Contact Details

Binarysoft Technologies
Authorized Tally Partner

�� Location:
1626/33, 1st Floor, Naiwalan, Karol Bagh,
New Delhi – 110005, INDIA

�� Contact Us:
+91 7428779101
+91 9205471661
+91 8368262875

�� Email:
tally@binarysoft.com

�� Business Hours:
10:00 AM – 6:00 PM (Mon–Fri)

Conclusion

• A single product should not have multiple GST rates
• If GST differs, create separate stock items
• Product details can be edited anytime in Tally Prime
• Correct setup ensures compliance, accuracy, and peace of mind

For professional guidance, GST-ready configuration, and reliable support, Binarysoft Technologies, an Authorized Tally Partner, is your trusted solution provider.

Frequently Asked Questions